I push past a group of brownshirts threatening a Jewish shopkeeper. They’re holding placards that read “Don’t buy from the Jews!” and accusing the owner of being a parasite on the German community. The woman inside cringes as I enter the shop and warns me the men outside won’t like it if I buy anything. But I insist and hand her my grocery list. At the end of the exchange I have three dialogue options: “There will be better times ahead,” “I’m so sorry,” and “I don’t know what to say.” All of them feel devastating and inadequate.
When you’re one person trying to resist the Nazi juggernaut in 1930s Germany, your best course of action is not at all obvious; indeed, anything you choose to do can often feel futile. There were so many occasions during Through the Darkest of Times that I questioned whether I was doing the right thing or if anything I did could even make a difference. Frequently, I simply didn’t know what to say. All I knew was that I had to keep fighting, keep surviving, keep resisting, and hope that it would be enough.
Through the Darkest of Times is billed as a historical resistance strategy game and plays out akin to a kind of narrative boardgame as you lead a band of as many as five freedom fighters against the Reich. Its story begins in 1933 as Hitler’s appointment as Chancellor confirms the Nazi party’s seizure of power. The four-act structure skips ahead to 1936 and the Berlin Olympics, to the occupation of France and invasion of the Soviet Union in 1941, and to the final months of the war, before a brief epilogue in 1946, a year after the Allied victory. The time periods it visits chart an emotional journey that feels authentic: Disbelief gives way to anger and fear as the truth about the Nazis’ goals is revealed; suffering and grief lead to the steeling of a righteous fury; and finally, glimpses of cautious optimism are tempered by an uncertain future.